Barbara Nadel – Enough Rope

Post by Enough-Rope-e1438263269855Crimepieces guest reviewer, Rachel Hall.

Barbara Nadel is familiar to many readers as the author of the well-regarded Inspector Ikmen series set in Istanbul, however my first encounter with her work comes with the fourth outing of the London based Hakim and Arnold series. Set in the East End, the series revolves around a small private detective agency run by white ex-policeman Lee Arnold and his assistant, young Muslim widow Mumtaz Hakim. Barbara Nadel has pulled off something quite special in Mrs Mumtaz Hakim. Mumtaz adds a layer of realism which offers a fresh perspective on an area which has seen vast changes over recent years and is largely unrecognisable to half a century ago.

With a significant Bangladeshi community making up a large part of the population around Brick Lane and the East End, Mumtaz has a solid support network established in the area. Well educated with a degree in psychology she is a strong independent woman working in an occupation still predominantly seen as the preserve of white males. As a step-mother to sixteen year old Shazia she has plenty of her own problems, burdened by the debts left by husband Ahmet to Naz Sheikh and his family and with their threats increasing being levelled at Shazia, not to mention brother Asif.

Whilst Lee hails from the Forest Gate area and as a divorced, ex-cop, ex-army private investigator could be seen as largely ‘old school’, he is clearly no dinosaur and is insightful enough to know that to make inroads in a community where the demographic is rapidly changing he needs support. The established crime families of the East End no longer reign and with a growing community of Muslims and a shift towards the upwardly mobile university elite, a more diverse community are bringing a wider range of crimes and corruption to his attention.

When Superintendent Paul Venus’ son, Harry, is kidnapped and a ransom demanded from an address in Brick Lane it is not just his boy he wants back; he also wants to know who is behind the sting and employs Arnold in an attempt to achieve a discreet resolution. Although by no means friends the pair and well aware of each other and with ex-colleagues still working under the authority of Venus, Lee has heard all the rumours of corruption and backhanders coming from on-off hook-up DS Violet Collins. Yet the ransom demand address of Brick Lane cannot be dismissed outright and when Mumtaz uncovers a connection which points to a powerful Bangladeshi family things no longer seem so straightforward. With Lee being sworn to secrecy about the case he has to tread very carefully and rely on the mutual trust which the pair have fostered.    Arnold has no contacts in the Muslim community, whereas Mumtaz has a family home and not only relatives but friends and connections to the community.

What Enough Rope lacked in frenetic action it more than made up for with its striking portrayal of life for the residents of a diverse East End and still delivered plenty of twists to keep me focused. Admittedly one outcome did strike me as rather contrived and a little left of centre but on the upside there was much to applaud. The supporting characters all have real depth, most noticeably Shazia, Vi Collins and father Baharat and I would be interested in seeing more of them. Well paced and a lively sense of humour in evidence throughout from both the old and new residents which I particularly liked. With Lee showing an increasing attraction to Mumtaz there may be a relationship on the cards but the bond between the pair seems genuine and adds a real plausibility which ensures that the series never feels like tokenism.

Originally hailing from the East End there is no doubt that Nadel is familiar with the cultures and communities who occupy the area. Gentrification and growing inequality fosters ill feeling, not just between the ‘haves and have nots’ but also between minority groups. The achievement which sets Enough Rope apart is in presenting individuals and a cross section of each ethnic group, not just depicting stereotypes. Most notably within Mumtaz’s family as brother Asif is increasing drawn to radicalisation it is her elderly father, Baharat, whose tolerance creates the lasting memory.

There was a sense of vibrancy throughout the novel and in the same way that Anya Lipska has brought the Polish community around Stratford alive, Barbara Nadel is doing a brilliant job for the Bangladeshi community of Brick Lane. I make no apologies for my new found enthusiasm for this series and if you enjoy a solid crime read with a little more of social context then this series is a very decent bet!


7 thoughts on “Barbara Nadel – Enough Rope

  1. I’m ashamed to say I’ve never read a Barbara Nadel either (note to self : read one!) but your quite excellent review – who needs Sarah? – (I’m joking Sarah!) certainly encourages me to look and see if I’ve any of her books in my overloaded Kindle! Again, a quite superb review!


      1. Absolutely – makes me want to buy the book immediately. I’m slightly embarrassed I haven’t read Barbara Nadel! Especially as she’s so prolific. Ditto Donna Leon – I haven’t read her either. Although I think I have a proof of hers, so the perfect excuse to read her! And Rachel is a wonderful stand-in while you’re so busy – she’s better than most book bloggers (including me!)


  2. Thank you so much Linda, really flattered and blushing! I have bought the rest of the Hakim and Arnold series and also one of the Inspector Ikmen to see how I find Istanbul. Doing these monthly reviews has provided me with my first reads from a few new authors, likewise with Lin Anderson. Have since added another Rhona to the TBR! Have found some great books that I would never have come across before! Xx


    1. I’ve discovered I’ve one of her Istanbul-set books from NetGalley, as well as a Donna Leon, which I’ve never read – I think it’s because the bookshop owner I worked for in the summer, which he spent with his wife in Venice (oh to be so lucky!) – didn’t rate them. Gosh, that was nearly 30 years ago, shows how long she’s been writing for! Lin Anderson isn’t bad, I’ve got a few of hers to catch up on. I’m sure Sarah must have a fine book collection, if she’s kept them all! I like to use second-hand shops to fill in gaps in my crime fiction collection – although I’m proud to say I managed to walk past my favourite today – it’s only 50p paperbacks/£1 hardbacks. That’s pretty hard to resist. And sometimes I’ve found the very latest books in there. That’s where I send all mine too!


      1. Hey Linda,

        It’s strange on Donna Leon as I keep trying to convince myself to give one a go, but they sound as if they are set in a bit of an arty, cultured location where they all quite high status and theatregoers.. Nothing wrong with that but I like the urban grit more. They have had her latest on paperback on a special bargain price in Waterstones and I have picked it up and put it down about three times now..

        My great bargain the other day was Heartman for 50p.. Saw they you loved that..!



  3. kathy d.

    Oh, I have to try this series, probably this book if my library has it. Or another if it doesn’t.
    And, as for Donna Leon, I love her books set in Venice. The protagonist is Commissario Guido Brunetti and his family members and questura colleagues are in every book.
    There isn’t a lot of action on Leon’s books. And Brunetti isn’t quick to act and there is no violence in the series, other than a murder or two off the page.
    He is a thinker about crimes, life, his family, the commercialism of his beloved Venice.
    But I enjoy these books and the last one, Leon’s 25th, The Waters of Eternal Youth, is an excellent one.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.