Hakan Nesser – The Weeping Girl

It seems that Hakan Nesser’s protagonist, Chief Inspector Van Veeteren, has been retired for his readers as he is only The Weeping Girlglimpsed in this book. It’s a mixed blessing when authors do this. On one hand the books don’t feel the same without a character that readers have seen develop throughout a series. However, as is the case with Arnaldur Indridason’s Inspector Erlendur who has been absent in the last couple of books on a quest to find his missing brother, removing the central protagonist does allow existing minor characters to bloom and come to the fore. This is the case in Nesser’s latest book The Weeping Girl.

DI Ewa Moreno from the Maardam Police has to interrupt her holiday to meet a suspect who has demanded that he speak only to her. On the train to the interview she encounters the weeping girl of the title, Mikaela, who tells Ewa that she has just discovered who her real father is: Arnold Maager, a man convicted of killing one of his students years earlier. She is in her way to the psychiatric unit where he is being held to meet him for the first time as an adult. When Mikaela suddenly disappears, followed soon after by her father, Ewa becomes drawn into the case much to her boyfriend’s dismay, while the suspect who she is interviewing drops a bombshell that shakes her faith in her colleagues.

The greatest strength of Hakan Nesser’s books is the consistency of his writing. He has a distinctive style, writing strongly plotted novels with a solid police procedural focus. One of his early books, Woman with Birthmark, would be in my top 10 Scandinavian crime novels and he has managed to maintain the quality in his subsequent books. The Weeping Girl is his eighth book to be translated into English and the absence of Van Veeteren allows the character of Ewa Moreno to open out. The book is particularly good at showing the dilemma of a policewoman who enjoys her freedom and independence along with the challenges of her job and the toll it takes on her personal life. Moreno has always been an interesting character but, as this book shows, she could easily hold a series of her own.

The plot seems a little slight compared to some of Nesser’s earlier books. His novels aren’t generally particularly complex; there is often a central mystery with the team working to solve it. The Weeping Girl doesn’t really deviate from this style but perhaps the ending which (no spoilers) teases the reader slightly with its revealing of the culprit which might have given the plot an insubstantial feel. Nevertheless, Nesser remains one of my favourite writers and I hope to read his next book, The Strangler’s Honeymoon later this month.

Thanks to the publisher, Pan, for sending me a copy of the book.

13 thoughts on “Hakan Nesser – The Weeping Girl

  1. Margot Kinberg

    Sarah – Thanks for an excellent review as ever. I agree completely that Nesser has a both a strong and a consistent writing style. What appeals to me too is that it is efficient. I like it when an author doesn’t get overly wordy. And in this case (and in The Unlucky Lottery), it’s nice to see that he’s allowed some of the other characters to ‘take the lead..’


  2. Sophie Orme

    Thanks for such a great, thoughtful review. Van Veeteren does take a back seat in a couple of the books in the series, but like you I loved getting to know Ewa better in The Weeping Girl. VV features brilliantly in The Strangler’s Honeymoon and then in the final case – The G File – we see him finally solve the case that has evaded him all these years, so lots to look forward to!


  3. Enjoyed reading your review. I have only read the first book, but became an instant fan at that point and bought books #2 and #3. I am sure I will enjoy the series whatever may come.


  4. Kathy D.

    I like Nesser’s books, too, and the character of Van Veeteren. Woman with Birthmark was also quite noteworthy among the panorama of crime fiction.
    The Hour of the Wolf saw a retired Van Veeteren come back into the picture for obvious reasons, but Ewa Moreno and some other male detectives were featured. It was a sad but solid read.
    One thing I miss in non-Van Veeteren book is the incredible sense of humor the author displays in his protagonist. One can be reading of a horrible murder scenario and Van Veeteren drops a hilarious comment.
    I miss that. Sometimes I am rendered speechless by the wit.
    I look forward to reading this book for reasons you mention above.


  5. Pingback: The Best of September’s Reading | crimepieces

  6. Pingback: The 2014 Petrona Award for the Best of Scandinavian Crime Fiction – Shortlist | crimepieces

  7. Pingback: Review: The Weeping Girl by Håkan Nesser | The Game's Afoot

Leave a Reply to Sarah Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.