Classic Crime: Ed McBain – Axe

Ed McBain is an author that I’ve flirted with over the years. As a teenager, the 87th Precinct books were readily available in my local library but didn’t quite do it for me. I’ve subsequently picked up a few books over the last couple of decades but never felt particularly inspired by the series. What has got me reading McBain again is thinking about the format of a police procedural after reading Maj Sjöwall and Per Wahlöö’s Martin Beck books which I’m still working my way through. I’ve discovered that there are many similarities between the two series and have started to enjoy the world of the 87th Precinct in the fictional city of Isola.

I’m not being as methodical reading McBain’s books; Detective Steve Carella started off with twins in the first novel I read and in the next one he was courting his future wife. However this is a series that can be read out of sequence without spoiling your enjoyment of it. I noticed I hadn’t been reviewing any of the books I’ve been reading, so I thought I’d set out my thoughts on the wonderfully illustrated (see opposite) Axe.

A janitor in an apartment building as been found with an axe wedged into his skull. Detectives in the 87th Precinct can find little in the way of a suspect although it comes to their attention that an illegal ‘crap-game’ has been taking place in the building’s basement, possibly with the collusion of the janitor. The dead man’s family consist of his mentally ill wife and his agoraphobic son. Both remain suspects despite the detectives’ instincts that both are innocent. When the next victim of the killer is a policeman from the 87th Precinct, outrage and threats of retribution mean that every cop is on the hunt for the killer.

Axe is number 18 in the 87th Precinct series and has many of the themes I’ve come to associate with McBain’s thrillers. Like in Cop Hater, the killing of a policeman is seen by his fellow officers to be the most despicable of crimes and you get the sense of everything halting until the perpetrator is found. As we would expect from McBain books, we get a series of snapshots of the city of Isola based on New York, filled with small time crooks and weary tenement dwellers. And without giving the end away, the motive of the crime is clearly the result of a minor misdemeanor that has been magnified by the perpetrator. This theme is explored further when a Rabbi is killed in The Empty Hours.

This is a short book and perhaps the mundane ending is a slight let-down as the sheer pointlessness of the killing is revealed. But McBain’s books are always been keen to show the reality of murder is often so different from the lurid portrayals in other instances of crime fiction.

An interesting review of Axe by a blogger who has clearly read more McBain than me can be found at Tipping my Fedora.

11 thoughts on “Classic Crime: Ed McBain – Axe

  1. Like you, I’ve never taken to this series in the way I have some others, but I’ve read one or two of them. This is a very nice review, as ever (also liked the one at Tipping my Fedora). Not sure it has tempted me to read this particular title but maybe will check out some of the others.


  2. Margot Kinberg

    Sarah – I’m glad you highlighted McBain’s novels. It’s a classic series and I’m happy that you were able to get back into the series enough to enjoy Axe. I’m not surprised at all that you find similarities with the Martin Beck series. From what I’ve read Maj Sjöwall and Per Wahlöö were influenced by McBain and vice versa. And you’re right that although some details (like Carella’s personal life) are best understood if one reads the books in order, it’s not at all necessary for a good enjoyment of the series.


  3. shelleyrae @ Book'd Out

    I discovered Ed McBain’s 87th Precinct series in my early 20’s and scoured second hand stores til I got my hands on the entire series. They were the spark for my love of police procedurals and have special place in my reading history 🙂


    1. How interesting Shelleyrae – I can see by your blog that you like crime books and thanks for the glimpse into your reading history. I discovered Sara Paretsky/Sue Grafton in my 20s and spent a lot of time catching up with these 2 writer’s books.


  4. Keishon

    Like you I’ve hopped around in this series. Some of the books in the series are clearly better than others. I’ve only been reading his books that are digitized and recommended to me by friends. I enjoy his books and his social commentary. His books are simply comfort reads for me. Thanks for reviewing this one.


  5. Pingback: Classic crime in the blogosphere, September 2012 | Past Offences

  6. Pingback: The Best of September’s Reading « crimepieces

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.