Review: Mons Kallentoft – Summertime Death

I was a little disappointed not to see the first book by Mons Kallentoft, Midwinter Sacrifice, on the International Dagger shortlist. I thought it an excellent début and I liked the multiple narrative voices. However, the book did get some mixed reviews and the style might not have been to everyone’s taste. Nevertheless, I was interested see how the second book by the writer, Summertime Death, would continue the series.

The setting for this latest book is the stultifying heat of summer in Linköping , a town in southern Sweden. The heat means that most of the population has left the town, including police detective Malin For’s daughter Tove and her ex-husband Janne. Although initially it looks like Malin will have a slow summer, the discovery of a young girl, naked and injured in the town’s botanical gardens means that they are looking for a particularly savage rapist. Unfortunately, the girl is unable to remember anything of the ordeal and the team have to rely on forensic evidence to try and find the perpetrator. When a second girl is murdered and the team can link together the two cases, the hunt is on to find the disturbed individual before he or she strikes again.

Summertime Death was a very enjoyable read which had me turning the pages as I raced to the denouement. The character of Malin Fors came across very well in the first book and I liked that fact that in the second, the author reined in the emphasis on Malin’s drinking and other problems and set her firmly in the investigation. However, when her ex-husband and daughter returned from Bali I felt the book lost some of its pace. I’m never convinced by plot devices where murderer stops choosing random victims and instead focuses on the family of the detectives. This clearly doesn’t happen in real life and I don’t think it particularly works in crime fiction.

The narrative voices contained in the book were all excellently done and movingly written. Kallentoft’s strength is his writing and, once again, I enjoyed his use of language and imagery. My only criticism would be that the structure was very similar to the first novel, for example with the narrative voice of a dead girl, and it would be nice to see the writer break out from this particular model and experiment more. There were some interesting assumptions made in the investigation, particularly relating to a lesbian angle to the assaults which I thought had been arrived at a slightly odd manner but the writer did follow through this thread to the end of the story.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Review: Mons Kallentoft – Summertime Death

  1. Sarah – A thoughtful, detailed and interesting review, for which thanks! And I’m so glad you mentioned that about the villain going after the sleuth’s family. I’m not saying it’s impossible but I’ve gotten a bit tired of that plot point… Still, I am interested in reading this. I like Malin’s character.

  2. A very good review, and I agree with your point about the murderer focusing on the detectives, particularly as a couple of clunky plot devices (eg an unforced error on the usually expert Malin’s part) were necessary to achieve this. I also thought in this context that her actions in the climactic scenes totally unbelievable and unforgiveable for any parent— however! I agree it is a page-turner, though I think he’s really overdone the “voices from the grave” aspects this time. In the first book there was some haunting quality to it, but this time it seemed just to be there for sensationalism.

  3. I’m disappointed that I didn’t like Midwinter Blood because the blurb for this appeals as much as the first one did, but I think I just have to admit its not a style that works for me.

  4. Pingback: The Best of June’s Reading « crimepieces

  5. While I enjoyed this read, I picked it up solely because it mentioned ‘The Killing’, ‘The Millenium Trillogy’ and ‘Jo Nesbo’. Having watched the first (both series the first time round), read the three books in that trilogy (before they became films) and even taken the Lisbeth Salander city tour when on business in Stockholme, and having heard ‘you must read this’ from my neighbour regarding a Nesbo novel; I clearly thought it would do more. Unfortuneately for Mons Kallentoft, I read Headhunters immediately after Summertime Death, and I just couldn’t put it down. It didn’t end there; when at work I thought about nothing bar the characters and the plot, and when I finished it it the next day I had withdrawal symptoms and mild depression. The Harry Hole series being my new addiction, I can assure prospective readers that ‘Summertime Death’ is NOTHING like a Nesbo novel. And that’s not just because it’s by a Swedish author and he’s Norwegian!

    • Thanks for dropping by Robyn. I agree that Kallentoft is nothing like Nesbo but I do still like this writer. It is the problem of book blurbs making spurious comparisons I think.

  6. Pingback: Review: Mons Kallentoft – Autumn Killing « crimepieces

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s