Reviews: Anne Holt – 1222 & The Final Murder

I read 1222 over Christmas when the wind was howling around the Derbyshire hills and I was ensconced in a warm house. It was an ideal winter read as it relates the story of train 601 from Oslo to Bergen that is derailed by a severe snowstorm. Trapped 1222 metres above sea-level, the train’s 269 passengers are forced to abandon their carriages and take refuge in a nearby hotel. The travellers are intrigued by an unseen passenger who is given special treatment and secreted in a separate wing of the hotel, patrolled by armed guards. The next morning, a body is found and the group turn to retired police inspector Hanne Wilhelmsen to help solve the crime. But Hanne, after a shooting at work, is confined to a wheelchair and with a snowstorm increasing in strength and a killer at large, a feeling of helplessness and panic spreads amongst the passengers.

I enjoyed this book mainly for the descriptions of the landscape and snowstorm. Each chapter is headed by a small description of each level of the Beaufort Scale. For example Chapter 1 begins “Beaufort Scale 0. Calm. Wind Speed 0-1 mph. Snowflakes fall vertically, often with a side-to-side motion”. And so on. I liked this little stylistic device which reflected the increasing intensity of the storm and killings in the book. Unfortunately I didn’t think the plot quite lived up to the atmosphere. I think the problem was partly the riddle mysterious stranger being guarded. This could have been quite an interesting plot line, but when it was partly revealed towards the end, I thought the explanation quite lame. I thought the investigation by Hanne quite well plotted but didn’t really identify with the detective and am not rushing to read any more books featuring Hanne.

I found The Final Murder a much more enjoyable read. The plot was good – a killer is targeting famous people in Oslo and leaving behind various disturbing symbols. The book opens with the murder of a talk-show host who is found with her tongue removed from her body and left on her desk, cleaved in two. It’s an interesting “serial killer” plot, and the passages interspersed in the book taking the killer’s point of view were well done and satisfactorily oblique.

I also liked the main detective, Superintendent Adam Stubo, already a grandfather with a new baby of his own. I suspect the fact that I hadn’t read Anne Holt’s earlier book Punishment might have been a slight disadvantage as I think his partner Johanne Vik had already featured in this book. I found it a bit hard to believe that a top policeman happened to have a partner who had just had a baby, who was also a former FBI profiler and now a psychologist. It’s all perfectly possible it’s just without any introduction it seemed a bit far-fetched. But I liked the plotting very much and thought it an excellent read. The ending was a bit frustrating for reasons I can’t say without spoiling the plot but I suppose, as a lawyer and former Minister of Justice, Anne Holt is aware that not all crimes can be resolved neatly.

Advertisements

13 thoughts on “Reviews: Anne Holt – 1222 & The Final Murder

  1. Excellent reviews, and I agree with your comparison of the two books. I hope you continue with the Stubo (who isn’t really called Adam, he has a Norwegian name but the publisher changed it to be more accessible to Eng Lan readers, how silly!)/Vik novels – I like those. I don’t think it matters that you haven’t read Punishment, which is more of a conventional police procedural/crime novel though the profile/forensic element is still there. The two subesequent ones are both easily available and good – I think the next is called Death in Oslo (?), about a visit to Norway by the US president. Very good in the build-up but the ending a let-down. Hanne is a minor-ish character in it. The newest one, Fear Not, I think extremely good, particularly in its treatment of hate crime at various levels of “granularity”. Anne Holt is a very interesting writer.

    • I would have thought that we’re well used to difficult Scandinavian names by now Maxine. I am going to add Anne Holt’s other books onto my reading list if they get better and better. She is a good writer.

  2. Sarah – What excellent reviews! Thanks. And I know exactly what you mean about the atmosphere/weather and growing sense of panic and how well they’re drawn in 1222. Sometimes settings like that do “trump” the plot. When that happens to me, I’m not eager to rush out and read the next story in the series, either. But I am glad you liked The Final Murder as much as you did.

  3. Pingback: George Clooney, Nespresso and #fridayreads « It's a crime! (Or a mystery…)

  4. I liked 1222 but agree it was quite silly – I have a bit of a thing for variations on the classic country house mystery though and I did like Hanne as a character (or maybe I should admit I identified with the curmudgeonly aspects of her personality)

    I haven’t read the final murder but it sounds like I should, I have FEAR NOT up soon on my audio book queue as it is eligible for the International Dagger this year and I am trying to read a few of those. I did read another of Holt’s called WHAT IS MINE that I thought rather good

  5. Hi, I’ve really been enjoying reading your reviews and I hope you don’t mind but I’ve nominated you for a Liebster Blog award. it’s for blogs with less that 200 followers (which I imagine is true of you as you’re pretty new) which out to have a wider audience. If you’d like to accept it just go back to my blog, copy the image, then if you want pass it onto another five deserving cases.

  6. Pingback: The best of January’s reading. « crimepieces

  7. Pingback: Review: Anne Holt – The Blind Goddess « crimepieces

  8. Pingback: Review: Anne Holt – Blessed Are Those Who Thirst | crimepieces

  9. Pingback: Review: Anne Holt – Death of the Demon | crimepieces

  10. Pingback: What Never Happens by Anne Holt | Ms. Wordopolis Reads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s