Review: Carol Topolski – Do No Harm

This unsettling book, Do No Harm by Carol Topolski, dropped on my doormat with the accompanying flyer which said “Everyone knows about Virginia: her stellar reputation as a gynaecologist…But does anyone know about the knives?’ Perhaps inevitably this book then sat on my bookshelf as I debated whether I really wanted to read about a gynaecologist with a penchant for cutting both herself and eventually other people. However I picked the book up the other day and read it through in virtually one sitting. It is a strange compulsive read with an assured narrative voice.

The central character is Dr Virginia Denham, a gynaecologist at a London hospital who is renowned in her profession for her dedication to patients. Tall and gangly, she clearly has issues with her body which she covers up in long sludge coloured clothes. The book is interspersed with passages from her childhood with her parents trapped in an unhappy marriage and looking for love and affection elsewhere. Virginia’s assistant in the hospital is Faisal who has educated himself out of his village in Kashmir and is happily married to Amina. His hero-worship of Virginia initially blinds him to her gradual slide into madness. Part of the narrative is also told through the eyes of Gilda who finds herself alone and pregnant and is treated at Virginia’s hospital. The burgeoning friendship between the two women is stalled by secrets in both their personal lives.

Topolski has a distinctive way of writing that is both accessible and compelling. From the very first page, the reader is drawn to the narrative with the killing of an unnamed woman. This actual murder is then not revisited until the final part of the book but the plot slowly builds up the tension and the context of the killing is revealed. The character of Virginia is very well drawn. She starves herself for days and then follows this with periods of gluttony in order to master her body. She is clearly struggling to control the rage she feels towards women who want to be mothers but are, in her eyes, undeserving.

‘Do no harm’ of course is one of the precepts of the Hippocratic Oath, that the doctor does nothing to the patient to make their condition worse. This book is in essence about what happens when the grip of madness takes over a woman whose natural impulse is to nurture her patients. I’m no expert on mental illness but the device by which the demonic ‘Ruby’ becomes the alter ego of Virginia  has plenty of literary precedents, not least with Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. Topolski is a practising psychoanalytic psychotherapist so she presumably has experience of patients with split personalities.

Despite the blurb at the back, the knife scenes weren’t too off-putting and I should know as I really can’t read anything too gory. Although this is a style of book I don’t read very often I found it to be a genuinely creepy read.

The book has been reviewed by Reading Matters and Fleur Fisher.

15 thoughts on “Review: Carol Topolski – Do No Harm

  1. I had been dithering about this book for a while, Sarah, not sure if it would be my cup of tea. Someone recommended the author to me, can’t remember who now. Quite a few of her books are in our local library so I may read this or another one, I am still not sure about it but clearly from your excellent review there are some good aspects that appeal, particularly the good writing style.

  2. an excellent review…but I shall probably skip this one anyway…in my day job I am surrounded by former doctors or doctors who are on a break from doctoring – mostly because of some mental illness or other – politically incorrect though it may be I am a bit ‘over’ the lot of ’em :)

  3. Sarah – This is an excellent review, for which thanks. It’s funny; I wasn’t sure I was going to read this one at all. Just not sure it would be something I’d want to read. But I am very glad you enjoyed it. I may give it a try; we’ll see…

  4. Very good review. Quite a talent to be able to write about such an offputting book and make one feel one might actually like to read it. Very good, Sarah! I think I will give it a try. I realized recently that I have been writing on my blog only about men writers! Time to write about a woman writer — but I’m not sure whether I will start here!

  5. Just a comment. i stumbled upon this website, due to a link from another website. I am so glad that I did. I just spent two hours reading reviews, and reluctantly I must stop so I can read The Invisible Ones and my newspaper. But I’ll be back very soon to continue doing this. What wownderful reviews and insights. Many books commented upon here I have read, many I haven’t but are on my TBR mountain.

    • Thanks Kathy and what a lovely surprise to wake up this morning and have so many comments. You clearly have read a lot of crime fiction including authors I’m just discovering. Enjoy The Invisible Ones which I liked a lot but has had mixed reviews. Glad you have enjoyed the reviews!

  6. Pingback: The Best of May’s Reading « crimepieces

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s