Review: Sue Grafton – V is for Vengeance

Like Elizabeth George, Sue Grafton is a writer whom I have been reading for years. What is remarkable about Grafton is her consistency in terms of her output and the quality of her writing. A is for Alibi first appeared in 1982 and she has more or less produced a book in the ensuing series every year or two. As readers of her books will know, they remain set in the 1980s and yet none of her books have a dated feel to them. The lack of mobile phones, internet and modern forensics are unmissed because the investigative aspect is so well written.

V is for Vengeance is set as usual in the fictional town of Santa Teresa. The book starts with the killing of a young college student who borrows money from Lorenzo Dante, head of a family steeped in organised crime, and then suffers heavy losses at a poker table. The relevance of this segment isn’t revealed until much later in the book. The action shifts to Kinsey Millhone who helps apprehend a woman shoplifter who then kills herself the following day. Kinsey is perplexed by the disproportionate reaction to what is a minor misdemeanor and her investigations begin when the shoplifter’s fiancée hires Kinsey to look into the suicide. In a parallel plot, Lorenzo Dante begins to look at way of getting out of the family business and away from his violent younger brother. When he encounters the glamorous Nora who is saddled with an unfaithful husband it seems their mutual desires might coincide.

I thought the investigation into the suicide of the shoplifter Audrey Vance absolutely fascinating. I’ve always associated shoplifting with schoolchildren and minor celebrities and had absolutely no idea that it was such big business and comes under the auspices of organised crime. The book is a mine of interesting information about this, such as the fact that when in a small shop the salesperson greets you it is often a way of deterring thieves who shy away from any personal contact. And I thought they were just being nice. The cutting off of tags around a kitchen table and the moving around of the stolen items was really fascinating and it seems that far more goods are stolen than shoplifters prosecuted.

Kinsey is her wonderful self and devotees of the series will need no summary of her virtues. All I will say is that once more I’m reminded of how influential the character of Kinsey Millhone has been on scores of later female detectives. Her character predates Kay Scarpetta and Barbara Havers although not, interestingly WI Warshawski who is was created virtually at the same time. The lovely Henry appears only briefly and I hope Grafton is saving him up for a larger part in her next book.

The only part of the book I had mixed feelings about was the Lorenzo Dante/Nora relationship. I loved Nora, she reminded me of those women you find in the novels of Jonathan Frantzen and Jeffrey Eugenides. Glamorous women whose polished appearance hides fractured marriages and unsavoury pasts. It was Lorenzo Dante I had a problem with. He’s just too nice for a Mafia boss and I felt the evil of the whole enterprise was glossed over.

But this is a minor complaint. I thought it was a better book than her last U is for Undertow and I felt Kinsey was back in her metier in a case embracing the underbelly of urban life.

There is a review of the book at Reactions to Reading and an interesting take on the audio book at Narrator Reviews.

12 thoughts on “Review: Sue Grafton – V is for Vengeance

  1. Sarah – An excellent review, for which thanks :-). I have to say that Sue Grafton is, in my opinion, one today’s more consistently solid and dependable, if that’s the word for it, writers. I’ve been hoping that this would live up to her standard (I confess I haven’t read it yet), and it’s good to hear that it does.

    • Thanks Margot and yes, I think Grafton’s consistency is amazing considering the length of time she has been writing. Her books are getting longer, but I think this is a publishing trend and hasn’t really detracted from the quality of the books.

  2. I’m really looking forward to reading this one too, but I haven’t read U is for Undertow yet. I’ve been reading Grafton and Sara Paretsky for ages too, and they started my interest in crime fiction. I’ve only read one Elizabeth George, though.

    • It’s a bit daunting when you have a lot of books to read in a series isn’t it? But i do think you can pick this book up and read it as a standalone and if you’ve read up to L you wil know the characters anyway.

  3. I’ve read them since the start, too, Sarah, and have enjoyed them more as the years went on, though I think they dipped in quality a bit around the middle of the alphabet, but then revived strongly. I am looking forward to reading this one (just was given it by a friend yesterday) so have not read your review in detail but will do so once I’ve finished the book.

  4. Pingback: The best of January’s reading. « crimepieces

  5. Pingback: Book review: V is for Vengeance by Sue Grafton | Petrona

  6. Very disappointed. As a detective story reader for over 50 years, and a Sue Grafton fan for all of her books up to now, I thought this was not up to her standard. The Mafia boss was too nice, Kinsey’s fondness for Pinky, who was a crook, and, what is worse, incredibly stupid, and finally, the denouement, where Kinsey was actually going to risk getting killed to attempt to save Pinky, frankly borders on stupidity. This struck me as a really fine author searching for a plot….and not finding it. And, finally, please spare us the private eye intent on solving a crime who has no paying client, and who is definitely in need of an income. Sue Grafton, you have been my favorite detective story author for so many years….for this one, you really let me down.


    • Hi Margery thanks for stopping by. I suppose it’s inevitable in a series as long as this that some books are better than others. I agree with your comments about some of the holes in the plot.

      I hope you keep reading Grafton, I think there’s life in Kinsey yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s